“Deciding When to Do What” How False Certainty Eliminates Options
A married couple who operates a family business recently asked to meet with me. Their relationship had reached a crossroads. Should they end the marriage or work to improve it?
I entered the conversation with a familiar bias: when a marriage is struggling, my instinct is to help the couple make it work.
He acknowledged being distant and uncommunicative. She wanted more openness and emotional vulnerability. "You ignore me," she told him.
As we talked, she began to recognize how critical she had become. He wanted less criticism and more understanding.
Both were hurting. Both had contributed to the distance between them.
Then something unexpected happened. I realized I didn't know what they should do.
For someone who has spent decades helping people navigate difficult relationships, that was an uncomfortable realization. I wanted to be the one they could trust to help turn things around.
But perhaps their marriage couldn't be saved. I found myself wondering whether separation might actually be the wiser choice.
My familiar assumptions were being challenged. I had come prepared to help them rescue their marriage. But was that what they needed from me?
The limits of certainty
It struck me that my singular focus on saving their marriage was interfering with my ability to help them discover what was best for them.
The experience reminded me of something I teach but don't always practice: when we become too certain about the right answer, we stop seeing alternatives.
A name for this is optionality: the freedom to recognize and seriously consider alternatives rather than remain captive to our habitual responses.
A time for everything
"When to do what?" is one of the great questions of leadership.
There's no automatic answer, and no formula.
The approaches that have served us well can become liabilities when we apply them indiscriminately. Wisdom requires recognizing when a different response is called for.
What worked yesterday may not be appropriate today.
Reflecting on the marriage conversation, I found myself returning to an ancient observation from Ecclesiastes: "To everything there is a season."
Here's my version, drawn from the relationships I live and work in:
There's a time to work things out and a time to part ways.
A time to give and a time to receive.
A time to make money and a time to give money away.
A time to say yes and a time to say no.
A time to speak up and a time to keep quiet.
A time to act and a time to wait.
A time to accommodate and a time to challenge.
How do you know when? What does any particular situation call for?
This is the hard part. We think we are choosing, when anxiety may be narrowing our choices.
Looking back, I wonder how much my determination to preserve their marriage reflected my difficulty accepting failures in my own relationships.
Anxiety has a way of making us dangerously certain. The more threatened we feel, the more attractive a single, unquestionable answer becomes, even when it’s unwise.
In families, businesses, politics, and public discourse, certainty is rewarded. Changing one's mind is often mistaken for weakness.
But there's a difference between having a conviction and being held captive by it. Between a decisive choice and an automatic response.
Increasing optionality means noticing when our habitual reactions are masquerading as thoughtful decisions.
A few questions can help:
What is my anxiety pushing me to do or say?
What does this particular situation require of me?
What does waiting cost? Some things ripen with time. Others rot.
None of these questions guarantee the right decision. Their purpose is to create enough space to consider alternatives.
The times we don't choose
Ecclesiastes isn't a how-to manual. Some seasons we choose, and others choose us: an illness, a death, a market that turns, a partner who's ready to call it quits.
Sometimes wisdom means accepting that the outcome isn't ours to determine.
I still believe struggling marriages deserve serious efforts at repair. But my responsibility was to help two people think more clearly about their own choices, not to decide for them.
I don't know what they'll decide. What I do know is that my certainty about what was best for them had begun to limit what I could see.
One of my big takeaways from this experience was seeing that my desire to be helpful interfered with my ability to be helpful.
When does doing what we’re sure of – or what we believe is right – become an obstacle to discovering what is actually needed?


Comments